◆ Methodology
Methodology
This page explains how Cmgray assesses new non-GamStop casinos before any of them appears in our comparison of 9 brands. These sites operate outside the UK Gambling Commission's framework, so UK players carry more risk and deserve to know exactly what we checked and what we could not. Before making a recommendation, we verify the licence and ownership, read the full terms, deposit and withdraw our own money, test support and safer gambling tools, and have a second editor review the findings. If a site fails on fundamentals, it is not listed.
The six areas we score
Trust and licensing
We confirm which authority issued the licence, check the number against the regulator's public register and identify who owns the operator. Because these sites sit outside the UK Gambling Commission and GamStop, we say so plainly and note what protections a UK player gives up.
Games and software
We look at which studios supply the lobby, whether return-to-player figures are published, how live tables perform on an ordinary UK broadband connection and whether game filters actually work. We play real-money sessions rather than relying on the casino's own descriptions.
Bonuses and terms
We read the full bonus terms, not just the banner. We record wagering requirements, maximum bet rules, game weighting, expiry dates and withdrawal caps, and we flag any clause that lets the operator void winnings on vague grounds such as irregular play.
Payments and withdrawals
We deposit our own money and request withdrawals, timing each one from request to arrival. We note which methods work for UK players, any fees, currency conversion from pounds, verification requests, and whether pending periods match what the cashier page promises.
Support and safer gambling
We contact live chat and e-mail with real questions and judge the accuracy of the replies, not just their speed. We also check for deposit limits, time-outs, self-exclusion and links to independent help such as GambleAware and GamCare, since GamStop does not apply here.
Mobile and UK fit
We test sites on ordinary iOS and Android phones, checking load times, cashier use and game stability. For UK fit, we look at pound sterling accounts, support available during sensible UK hours, clear British English and whether the terms treat UK residents fairly.
Our step-by-step review process
- Shortlisting new brands. We start with operators that have launched recently or relaunched under new ownership. A brand only enters testing if we can identify the company behind it, its licensing authority and a complete, working set of published terms and conditions.
- Verifying licence and ownership. We check the licence on the regulator's own register, compare the company name with the one in the site footer, and search for past complaints or sanctions linked to the same owners. Any mismatch at this stage stops the review.
- We review each site's terms, licences, payment methods and public reviews before it is listed or re-scored. A team member registers with genuine details, just as a UK player would. We note what information is requested, whether the sign-up process is clear, and whether marketing consent boxes are pre-ticked or tucked away in the process.
- Reading every term. Before claiming anything, we read the general terms, bonus terms and privacy policy in full. We record the clauses on dormant accounts, winnings caps, bonus abuse and document checks, because these are where disputes usually begin.
- Depositing our own money. We fund the account using methods a UK player is likely to use, such as cards, e-wallets or cryptocurrency where offered. We record minimum deposits, fees, processing times and whether the amount credited matches the amount sent.
- Playing real sessions. We play slots, table games and live dealer titles across several sessions on desktop and mobile. We note crashes, slow loading, missing game information and whether the displayed balance stays accurate throughout play.
- Testing bonus conditions. Where a welcome offer is fair enough to be worth testing, we claim it and track wagering progress against the stated terms. We check whether restricted games are clearly marked and whether support explains the rules consistently.
- Requesting withdrawals. We request a withdrawal and time it from submission to arrival. We record any verification requests, how long documents take to be approved, whether limits match the terms, and whether the operator tries to reverse or delay the payment.
- Contacting customer support. We ask support several practical questions, including how to set limits or close an account. We check the answers against the published terms. A friendly but inaccurate answer counts against the site rather than in its favour.
- Editorial review and scoring. The tester's notes go to a second editor, who checks the evidence and challenges the scores. Only then is the review published, showing the testing date and setting out the strengths and weaknesses plainly.
What we pay special attention to
- We pay close attention to whether the operator behind a new brand has run other casinos, and how those casinos treated their players.
- We note whether withdrawal limits and verification rules are disclosed before a deposit or only revealed when a player asks to cash out.
- We check that safer gambling tools can be switched on by the player directly, without having to persuade support staff.
- We look for clear, consistent information in plain English, since vague or contradictory wording often signals weak oversight.
- We compare what support tells us with what the terms say, because inconsistent answers are a common source of disputes.
A casino scores lower if we find
- A licence we cannot verify on the regulator's own register lowers a score immediately and usually stops the review altogether.
- Bonus terms that allow winnings to be voided for undefined irregular play count heavily against a site.
- Withdrawals that take far longer than the cashier page states, or that involve repeated document requests, reduce the payments score.
- Missing or hard-to-find deposit limits, time-outs and self-exclusion options lower the safer gambling rating.
- Pressure tactics such as countdown offers, pre-ticked marketing consent or repeated prompts to reverse a withdrawal are marked down.
How reviews get updated
New casinos change quickly, so we revisit each of the 9 brands regularly rather than treating a review as finished. We recheck terms, bonus offers and payment methods whenever an operator announces changes, and we repeat a deposit and withdrawal when reader reports or our own monitoring suggest something has changed. A change of ownership or licence triggers a full retest. Every review shows the date it was last checked, so readers can judge how current the information is.
Corrections & updates → · Rachel Whitmore →
Frequently Asked Questions
Why review casinos that are not on GamStop?+
Some UK adults choose these sites regardless, often after seeing aggressive advertising elsewhere. We think they are better served by honest, tested information than by silence. Our reviews explain the reduced protections clearly, and we do not encourage anyone who has self-excluded through GamStop to look for ways around it. If that applies to you, please contact GamCare instead.
Do casinos pay to be included or ranked higher?+
No. Some links on Cmgray are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission when a reader signs up. That arrangement never buys a place on the list or a higher score. Rankings follow the testing process set out on this page, and a partner that falls short is marked down or removed like any other brand.
Who carries out the testing?+
Testing is led by Rachel Whitmore, our Senior Casino Analyst, with support from editors James Harcourt, Sophie Langley and Daniel Price. Each review is tested by one person and checked by another, so no single editor's impressions decide a score. The names on each review show who tested it and who reviewed the evidence.
What should I do if my experience differs from your review?+
Please write to editor@cmgray.net with the casino name, the date of the issue, and screenshots or correspondence where possible. We treat player reports as leads to investigate rather than as automatic changes. If we can confirm the problem, we update the review and note the change on the page so readers can see what was corrected.